World Cup 2026: Shearer and Cole stunned as Tuchel eyes bold Marc Guehi call ahead of Croatia clash

England’s build-up to their World Cup opener has been overshadowed by fresh selection controversy, with Thomas Tuchel’s reported defensive plans leaving pundits Alan Shearer and Joe Cole openly baffled.

The new England manager has already made headlines before a ball is kicked in anger, with several high-profile names left out of his tournament squad.

Phil Foden, Lewis Hall, Harry Maguire and Cole Palmer were among the major omissions as Tuchel signalled a ruthless approach ahead of a bid to end England’s long wait for global glory.

That mission begins on Wednesday night against Croatia in Group L, a section that also includes Ghana and Panama, but attention has been diverted from the opposition to Tuchel’s defensive dilemma.

Guehi decision sparks confusion

Reports emerging ahead of kick-off suggest Marc Guehi is set to be left out of the starting XI in favour of a more experienced option, with John Stones expected to partner Ezri Konsa at the heart of defence.

The decision has raised eyebrows across the footballing landscape, particularly given Stones’ limited minutes at club level this season compared to his international peers.

The sense of disbelief was echoed strongly by Shearer, who questioned the logic behind the reported call.

“I would start Guehi and Konsa, just because of Stones’ lack of football, he didn’t play much this season and this is obviously a very important game,” he said.

“So I would go with Guehi and Konsa. It will be a big surprise if Guehi is left out, not many people wouldn’t have started Guehi in this first game.”

Cole backs Guehi as defensive standout

Joe Cole was equally firm in his assessment, going as far as describing Guehi as England’s standout central defender in the current setup.

“Same. For me Marc Guehi is the number one centre half in the squad,” he said.

“John Stones is a fantastic player and if he can get to the levels he’s got to before he’s England’s best defender. But Guehi was incredible this season. I find it strange that they’re even talking about not playing him.”

Pressure mounts on Tuchel’s first major call

Tuchel now faces immediate scrutiny over one of his first major tournament decisions, with England fans eager for stability as the side chase a first major trophy since 1966.

The German coach’s willingness to make bold calls has already defined his early tenure, but the opening match against Croatia will be the first true test of whether his judgement delivers results or fuels further debate.

With final team selection still under wraps, the focus remains firmly on the back line, where one decision could shape England’s entire World Cup trajectory.