Why selling Amad Diallo in January could be Mauricio Pochettino’s first big mistake at Manchester United
Mauricio Pochettino has been urged to resist the temptation to offload Amad Diallo when the January transfer window opens, with the Manchester United winger’s contributions over the past two seasons highlighting why he remains an important asset at Old Trafford.
The Ivorian has reportedly emerged as a transfer target for Turkish giants Besiktas, who are preparing to strengthen their attacking options ahead of the second half of the 2026/27 campaign.
Besiktas are expected to part ways with Milot Rashica during the winter window and are also considering offers for Vaclav Cerny, prompting the club to identify potential replacements.
Reports in Turkey suggest Amad is among their preferred options, with the 24-year-old valued at approximately €45 million (£37.5 million).
However, with Pochettino beginning his tenure as Manchester United manager, allowing the winger to leave could prove a costly decision as the Argentine looks to rebuild the team’s attacking identity.
Amad’s numbers make strong case for retention
Although Amad has endured an underwhelming start to the 2026/27 season, registering just one assist in nine appearances across all competitions, his overall contribution to United since the beginning of the 2024/25 campaign makes a compelling argument for keeping him.
The winger has recorded 12 assists during that period, placing him second among Manchester United players, behind only captain Bruno Fernandes.
His 13 goals also represent one of the best returns in the squad, with only Fernandes (34), Bryan Mbeumo (16), Benjamin Sesko, Casemiro and Matheus Cunha (14 each) scoring more.
Amad’s influence extends beyond goals and assists, particularly in his ability to progress possession and create opportunities for teammates.
He has attempted 1,180 passes in the final third since the start of the 2024/25 season, the third-highest figure among United players.
His 83.14 per cent completion rate in that area also compares favourably with Fernandes and Diogo Dalot, while his overall passing accuracy stands at 87.32 per cent.
Only Fernandes has created more chances than Amad’s 155 during the same period, with the Ivorian also ranking second at the club for big chances created, registering 19.
Pochettino could lose one of United’s most effective creators
Amad’s attacking qualities are further underlined by his crossing statistics.
Among Manchester United players who have attempted more than 20 crosses since the beginning of the 2024/25 campaign, none has matched his 32.79 per cent completion rate.
The winger has also demonstrated his defensive contribution, ranking among the club’s top five players for one-on-one duels.
Although his 105 attempted tackles place him outside the top 10, his 71.43 per cent success rate is the best among his teammates.
Those numbers highlight a player capable of contributing at both ends of the pitch, offering Pochettino tactical flexibility as he considers how to organise his attacking options.
While his recent form may raise questions about his immediate impact, his performances over a longer period suggest that United would be giving up a valuable player if they entertained Besiktas’ interest.
Pochettino faces early transfer decisions
Pochettino’s arrival at Old Trafford presents an opportunity for Manchester United to establish a more consistent direction after several managerial changes.
The Argentine will be expected to identify the players who fit his philosophy and make important decisions about the squad ahead of the January transfer window.
Having previously managed Southampton, Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea, he arrives with considerable Premier League experience and a reputation for developing attacking players.
However, he will have limited time to assess his squad before decisions on potential arrivals and departures become necessary.
Amad’s situation could therefore become one of his first significant tests, particularly with Besiktas reportedly monitoring his availability.
The winger has not publicly indicated any desire to leave Manchester United, and his statistical contributions provide little justification for the club to push him towards the exit.
Pochettino may eventually decide that some players are surplus to requirements as he shapes the squad to his preferences, but Amad’s creativity, versatility and defensive work rate make him a player worth retaining.
For a club desperate to restore its position among England’s leading sides, allowing one of its most productive attacking players to leave midway through the season could be an unnecessary setback.
Pochettino’s priority should be to get the best out of Amad rather than sanction his departure, especially when the winger has already demonstrated his ability to influence games at Old Trafford.
