Premier League clubs have agreed to cover the legal costs of the league’s board if sponsors of Manchester City bring personal claims against its members, in an unprecedented move in English football.
The decision was taken at a meeting of club owners and executives in London on Thursday, the first since an independent commission ruled against Manchester City in September.
One club voted against the proposal, according to sources familiar with the outcome who spoke anonymously because they were not authorised to comment publicly. The result was also confirmed to The Athletic.
The agreement would provide financial protection for Premier League chief executive Richard Masters if he were sued. It also covers the league’s four other board members: chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors May Fifield, Darmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder.
The meeting took place at the Savoy Hotel in central London and began with the vote on the issue. Sources said the debate was brief and that neither Manchester City nor its sponsors were explicitly named.
The stated purpose of the arrangement is to allow the Premier League board to carry out its duties and make decisions in the interests of the clubs and the competition without favouritism or discrimination. However, the clubs did not agree a maximum contribution for each member.
Sponsors consider legal response
Etihad Airways, Manchester City’s long-standing shirt sponsor and stadium naming-rights partner, said in September that it was considering legal action after the independent commission found the club guilty of more than 100 breaches of financial rules between 2009 and 2018.
The commission found that Manchester City had artificially inflated revenue and reduced costs through “disguised financing” arrangements, including “fake” contracts and agreements that had been “fabricated” to conceal capital contributions and investment from the club’s owner, United Arab Emirates-based City Football Group.
It concluded that the club’s conduct “clearly demonstrates an intention to circumvent the Premier League rules”. In a Premier League statement, Masters said Manchester City had “systematically breached the rules” for “nearly 10 years”.
Etihad Airways told The Athletic it “categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that the airline was involved in any improper commercial arrangements”.
The airline said it was “deeply concerned about the manner in which this matter has been publicised” and that “the lack of clarity and transparency, combined with selective disclosure of information, has caused damaging effects to Etihad Airways, despite the fact that it was not named in the published decision”.
It added: “Etihad Airways will consult with specialist legal counsel regarding the legal options and remedies available to protect its interests.”
In a statement to The Times on 16 November, another Manchester City sponsor, Etisalat UAE Telecommunications Company, said the Premier League’s published findings relating to Etisalat were “entirely false and defamatory”. It added that it was “seriously considering all options relating to its rights and the legal remedies available in this matter”.
Manchester City has appealed against the ruling, which could result in relegation, and continues to deny the allegations. That process remains ongoing.
The decision creates the potential situation in which Manchester City would have to help fund the defence of Masters and the board if its own sponsors sued them.
Elsewhere, Howard Webb, the chief refereeing officer, gave an update on officiating. The meeting also included ongoing discussions about an agreement with the English Football League, but no vote was held on that matter.
