Pochettino faces early Fernandes dilemma before Manchester United’s Anfield test

Share This Article:
Pochettino faces early Fernandes dilemma before Manchester United’s Anfield test

Mauricio Pochettino’s first major decision as Manchester United manager is likely to centre on captain Bruno Fernandes before Sunday’s visit to Anfield.

The new boss will have to decide whether to retain the Portugal international in a struggling side or leave out one of its most influential players, with the consequences of either choice potentially significant for a club sitting in the bottom three.

Fernandes, 32, remains central to United despite failing to match his best form this season. He has scored four goals and provided two assists in nine Premier League starts, while also scoring in Portugal’s 3-2 Nations League victory over Wales on Tuesday.

His importance was even greater during a historic 2025/26 campaign, when he broke the single-season Premier League assists record and won the Football Writers’ Player of the Year award.

But his influence has also become a source of tension. The breakdown under Michael Carrick, which ultimately cost the manager his job, highlighted a conflict between Fernandes’ instinct to take risks and the collective discipline required by the team.

After United’s 4-1 Champions League defeat by Como last month, Fernandes criticised the tactical approach in public, saying it lacked the bravery to press high. Carrick responded by questioning players who failed to run forward or track back.

The dispute went beyond individual pressing. Fernandes regularly abandons his central position to receive possession from the centre-backs, potentially blocking passing lanes for players such as Kobbie Mainoo, before attempting an ambitious first-time pass into advanced areas.

When those passes fail, United can be left exposed during defensive transitions. Fernandes is also accused of switching off and allowing late runners to go untracked, while his visible frustration and arm-waving can further unsettle a fragile team.

Pochettino’s football is built around coordinated pressing, positional discipline and patient control of territory. The former Tottenham and Chelsea manager has previously shown a willingness to place his system above established dressing-room hierarchies.

At Tottenham, he marginalised senior figures including Emmanuel Adebayor and Younes Kaboul after arriving in 2014, instead building around a younger core led by 21-year-old Harry Kane and Dele Alli.

At Chelsea in 2023, Pochettino overlooked veteran players to give the captaincy to 23-year-old academy graduate Reece James and relied heavily on a young Enzo Fernandez as part of a cultural reset.

That history raises another question at Old Trafford: who could replace Fernandes as captain?

Harry Maguire would represent a return to an already contested past, particularly with a back problem affecting his fitness. Matthijs de Ligt captained Ajax as a teenager but is still trying to establish authority in an unreliable defence.

Lisandro Martinez has the temperament of an old-fashioned defensive leader, yet his public outburst at United director of football Jason Wilcox has fuelled doubts about whether his volatility could help steady the club.

Kobbie Mainoo may therefore offer Pochettino an alternative. The 21-year-old academy graduate has the composure, press resistance and clean slate that could appeal to his new manager, although asking a quiet midfielder to help rescue a relegation-threatened giant would carry obvious risks.

With Fernandes’ contract due to expire next summer, a 12-month extension option pending and interest from the Saudi Pro League, Pochettino’s decision could shape United’s immediate future. His team selection at Anfield may indicate whether Fernandes remains central to the recovery or whether United begin preparing to cope without him.

Share This Article: