Orlando Pirates have been placed on alert by the reported appointment of Abdel Aziz Bouh as referee for their CAF Champions League Group C opener against Simba SC in Tanzania on Sunday, 29 November.
The Mauritanian official was in charge of Mamelodi Sundowns’ controversial 1-0 defeat by Raja Casablanca in the group stage in January 2025, a match that ended with intense post-match debate over the officiating.
Three players were sent off during the fiery encounter in Casablanca, with Mamelodi Sundowns reduced to nine men before the final whistle.
Bathusi Aubaas was shown a straight red card in the first half following a studs-up challenge on Younes Najjari. Raja Casablanca then lost Marouane Zila, who was dismissed for a challenge on Teboho Mokoena.
Khuliso Mudau received the third red card late in the match after striking Nawfel Zerhouni in the face.
Raja’s winner also prompted protests from Mamelodi Sundowns. Benaissa Benamar scored in first-half stoppage time, but Miguel Cardoso’s side appealed for offside.
The officials, and Bouh in particular, were criticised at the time amid suggestions that the intimidating atmosphere created by the Casablanca crowd had influenced decisions.
Bouh’s previous performance does not establish any wrongdoing, but his reported appointment is another concern for Orlando Pirates as they prepare to face Simba SC in Dar es Salaam.
South African clubs’ difficult history in Tanzania
South African teams have previously raised concerns about their treatment in CAF competitions against Simba SC.
In 2022, former Orlando Pirates assistant coach Mandla Ncikazi publicly complained about the conditions his side encountered during a visit to the Tanzanian club. He later apologised to CAF after Simba SC, also known as The Red Lions, lodged a complaint.
Kaizer Chiefs also voiced concerns about possible “dirty tricks” before their 2021 CAF Champions League quarter-final against Simba SC.
Kaizer Chiefs won the first leg 4-0 at home in May 2021, then suffered a 3-0 defeat in the return match in Tanzania. They nevertheless progressed 4-3 on aggregate.
Orlando Pirates will begin their Group C campaign away against Wekundu Wa Msimbazi, another name used for Simba SC.
The South African club can, however, take some reassurance from reports that the Video Assistant Referee system will be used in every CAF Champions League match from the group stage onwards.
That could provide an additional review mechanism in a fixture already attracting attention because of the match official and the previous experiences of South African clubs in Dar es Salaam.
