Kaizer Chiefs’ cup history faces Sundowns’ recent Carling Knockout dominance
Kaizer Chiefs will draw on a strong record against Mamelodi Sundowns in the Carling Knockout when the sides meet in Sunday’s semi-final at Loftus Versfeld Stadium.
The match on 22 November is scheduled to kick off at 15h30 and will be the 10th meeting between the clubs in the competition. Their first encounter came in 1983, when Chiefs went on to win their first League Cup title.
Chiefs lead the head-to-head record
Amakhosi have won six of the nine previous Carling Knockout meetings, although three of those victories came via penalty shootouts. Sundowns have won twice, while the other match ended in a draw before Chiefs prevailed in a replay.
That record gives Chiefs the historical advantage, particularly in the competition’s decisive stages. However, the recent results between the clubs present a tougher challenge for the side seeking to reach the final.
Sundowns have won the past two Carling Knockout meetings. They defeated Chiefs 3-1 in the 2015/16 final before recording a 4-0 victory in the quarter-finals of the 2024/25 campaign.
The latter result was the biggest margin of victory in the nine previous matches between the teams in the competition. Peter Shalulile, Iqraam Rayners and Khuliso Mudau played key roles in Masandawana’s dominant performance, with Rayners scoring twice, including a penalty.
Chiefs’ record from the spot
Chiefs’ success in this fixture has often come when matches have gone beyond regulation time.
They have beaten Sundowns on penalties three times, with all three victories coming in finals. In the 1997/98 campaign, a 1-1 draw was followed by another 1-1 result in the replay, before Chiefs won the shootout 3-2.
A year later, Amakhosi again triumphed on penalties, defeating Sundowns 2-1 after a 2-2 draw in the 1998/99 final. Their third shootout success came in the 2007/08 final, when Itumeleng Khune overcame his mentor Brian Baloyi in a contest famously framed as a battle between Spider Kid and Spider Man.
Chiefs’ three outright wins in the competition came against Sundowns in 1983, when they won 2-0, in 1986, when they prevailed 1-0, and in the 2009/10 quarter-finals, when Mandla Masango scored the only goal.
Sundowns’ two outright victories have both come more recently: the 3-1 win in the 2015/16 final and last season’s 4-0 quarter-final success.
Chiefs also hold wider cup advantage
Across all cup competitions, the supplied head-to-head figures show 34 meetings between the clubs. Chiefs have won 14 in regulation time and six on penalties, giving them 20 victories overall. Sundowns have eight regulation-time wins and two shootout victories, while three matches have been drawn.
The latest cup meeting outside the Carling Knockout came in the 2024/25 Nedbank Cup semi-final. Sundowns scored first, but Chiefs recovered to win 2-1 and reach the final.
Chiefs therefore have the stronger historical record, while Sundowns have scored seven goals and conceded one in the last two Carling Knockout meetings. The semi-final will decide whether Amakhosi’s cup pedigree or Masandawana’s recent dominance carries greater weight.
