Gerard Pique: Jesus Ono punished for tragedy, not the action itself

Share This Article:

Gerard Pique has criticised the decision to suspend goalkeeper Jesus Ono for 12 matches following the fatal collision that led to the death of Tenerife striker Jesus de Miguel.

The former Barcelona defender described the punishment as harsh and unjust, arguing that the incident was accidental and that Ono was being held accountable for an outcome he could not have intended or controlled.

Pique’s comments, reported by Spanish radio station COPE, have sparked debate in Spain. Some believe the need to protect players’ lives justifies severe sanctions, regardless of intent, while others agree with Pique that disciplinary action should be based on what a player did rather than the tragic consequences that followed.

“I believe the punishment should be imposed for the action itself, not for its consequences,” Pique said. He added that several professional footballers and coaches had described the collision as accidental, meaning it should not be treated as deliberate or reckless conduct deserving the maximum penalty.

To illustrate what he sees as an inconsistency, Pique referred to an incident at Albacete’s stadium during the same weekend. Corpas Cuadri struck a Sabadell player in the head in a similar challenge, but the competition committee issued a three-match suspension because there was no fatal injury.

That comparison led Pique to question how the same act could result in a three-match ban in one case and 12 matches in another when the only difference was a tragic outcome that nobody intended.

Pique recalls collision with Victor Valdes

Pique also drew on a painful experience from his own career. During the 2012 Champions League semi-final against Chelsea, he collided with his former Barcelona team-mate and goalkeeper Victor Valdes.

“Two bodies move at high speed in opposite directions, both focused on the ball, and then they suddenly collide. One of them will always be injured more seriously than the other,” Pique said.

He explained that he lost consciousness in the incident and had to be taken to hospital. However, Valdes was never considered responsible for the injury and nobody called for him to be punished, because it was understood to have been an accident in a sport built on speed and physical force.

“Giving Jesus Ono the maximum punishment puts him in an unfair position because he is not responsible for what happened,” Pique added.

Pique said the incident had also left a lasting emotional impact on those involved. He was in Tenerife when it happened and witnessed the shock experienced by the players.

“When I went into the dressing room and saw our players’ reactions, I realised this was something that would stay with us for the rest of our lives,” he said.

Pique maintained that the collision was entirely accidental and said Ono was now enduring one of the most difficult periods of his life.

Share This Article: