Former referee says Lionel Messi red card was warranted after Columbus Crew incident

Share This Article:
Former referee says Lionel Messi red card was warranted after Columbus Crew incident

Lionel Messi should have been sent off for deliberately striking Columbus Crew forward Gonzalo Tapia with the ball, according to former English referee Graham Scott.

The incident occurred during Inter Miami’s 3-0 home defeat by Columbus Crew, after Messi became involved in a confrontation with Tapia late in the first half.

Tapia had attempted to prevent Messi from taking a quick throw-in, prompting an angry response from the Argentina forward. Messi then threw the ball towards Tapia’s face with considerable force, sending the Chilean to the ground.

Referee Allen Chapman intervened and booked both players. However, he did not show Messi a red card, despite protests from Columbus Crew players. Footage showed the ball clearly striking Tapia in the face, placing the decision under renewed scrutiny and reigniting debate over whether high-profile players receive different treatment from match officials.

Scott said the more appropriate punishment would have been a dismissal.

“If referee Chapman had shown a red card, it would have been the more accurate decision under the laws of the game; the force used was excessive and completely unnecessary,” he told The Athletic.

Scott also reposted The Athletic’s coverage on X, adding: “A deserved red card in my opinion; it was an unjustified, deliberate and violent act.”

He continued: “I could easily have misread this incident too; referees often make mistakes when interpreting rare situations, as I cannot remember a similar event during the 20 years I spent officiating professional matches.”

Heavy defeat leaves Inter Miami under pressure

The controversy formed part of a disastrous evening for Inter Miami, who were beaten 3-0 by Columbus Crew in the opening match of their first-round Major League Soccer play-off series. The tie is being played under a best-of-three format.

Columbus took the lead in the eighth minute when Gonzalo Tapia converted a penalty. The spot-kick was awarded after Inter Miami goalkeeper Dane St. Clair brought down Tapia inside the penalty area.

Inter Miami’s task became harder in the 36th minute when Gonzalo Lujan was sent off after receiving a second yellow card, leaving the hosts to play the rest of the match with 10 men.

Columbus extended their advantage seven minutes into the second half through Taha Habroune. Tapia then completed his brace and made it 3-0 in the 58th minute.

Messi had two strong chances before half-time, but Columbus goalkeeper Patrick Schulte denied him on both occasions and completed the match with a clean sheet after an impressive performance.

The result carries added significance for Inter Miami, the reigning Major League Soccer champions. They must now win away from home against Columbus on 27 November to force a third and decisive match. A defeat would end their play-off campaign.

Share This Article: