English FA explored legal action to block Gianni Infantino’s fourth term as Fifa president
The English Football Association (FA) has explored the possibility of mounting a legal challenge against Gianni Infantino’s eligibility to seek a fourth term as Fifa president but believes the move is unlikely to succeed.
The governing body considered challenging the decision to disregard Infantino’s initial three-year spell in office when calculating the maximum presidential term limit.
However, after examining the circumstances surrounding the decision, the FA has concluded that an attempt to prevent the Swiss-Italian from contesting the March election would probably fail.
FA chair Debbie Hewitt confirmed the position in a response to human rights campaign group Fair Square, which had urged the association to challenge Infantino’s eligibility.
The FA has also declared its support for Philippe Diallo, president of the French Football Federation, as a rival candidate to the incumbent.
Infantino became Fifa president in 2016 after succeeding Sepp Blatter, who resigned amid a major corruption scandal.
Under the governing body’s statutes, presidents are restricted to a maximum of three terms. However, Fifa’s council ruled in 2022 that Infantino’s initial period between 2016 and 2019 should not count towards that limit.
The decision meant his first spell, which covered the remainder of Blatter’s interrupted final term, was excluded from the calculation, allowing him to remain eligible for another election.
FA doubts legal challenge would succeed
Fair Square recently wrote to the FA arguing that the decision to disregard Infantino’s first term could be challenged because it contradicted the intention behind Fifa’s presidential term limits.
The organisation urged the English association to refer the matter to Fifa’s governance committee and seek to have Infantino barred from the March election.
However, Hewitt revealed that the FA had already examined the possibility but was unconvinced that a legal challenge would produce the desired outcome.
In correspondence seen by the BBC, she explained that the process leading to the decision had followed Fifa’s internal governance procedures.
“The FA has explored the possibility of challenging Mr Infantino’s eligibility to run for a further term as the Fifa president but does not consider that such a challenge would secure the outcome sought,” Hewitt wrote.
“Ultimately the process followed Fifa’s governance and led to an outcome where Mr Infantino’s part term was disregarded for the purposes of maximum term limits.
“Having considered the process in detail, we do not believe that a challenge would succeed.”
The response effectively signals the FA’s reluctance to pursue the matter through formal legal channels despite questioning Infantino’s eligibility.
Fair Square urges FA not to abandon challenge
Fair Square has criticised the FA’s position, arguing that refusing to pursue the matter could weaken efforts to hold Fifa’s leadership accountable.
The campaign group believes the association should continue seeking explanations over why Infantino’s initial three years in office were excluded from the term-limit calculation.
“It’s understandable that the FA has no faith in Fifa’s internal processes to hold Infantino accountable for serious breaches of the rules, but it’s a mistake to abandon these channels, not least because it sends a signal to Infantino that he can do whatever he likes,” Fair Square said in a statement.
“We will encourage the FA to leave its options open where this matter is concerned not least because Debbie Hewitt’s position on the Fifa council puts her in a very strong position to demand clear answers on why Fifa discounted Infantino’s first term.”
Meanwhile, Miguel Maduro, a former head of Fifa’s governance committee, has suggested that a national football association or continental confederation could take the matter to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS).
However, Maduro has also highlighted complications surrounding a potential challenge from European football associations.
He believes Uefa president Aleksander Ceferin’s decision to seek a fourth term, after previously indicating in 2024 that he would not stand again, has made it more difficult for European associations to challenge Infantino’s eligibility.
FA backs Diallo after withdrawing support for Infantino
The FA’s position comes after it joined other national associations in withdrawing support for Infantino following controversy surrounding his proposed plan to sell stakes in the World Cup and other Fifa competitions to private investors.
The development further underlines the division surrounding the Fifa presidency ahead of the March election.
Uefa has already declared its support for Diallo, who leads the French Football Federation, as an alternative to Infantino.
Despite the growing opposition, the incumbent remains eligible to contest another term following Fifa’s 2022 interpretation of the presidential term limits.
The FA’s latest position suggests it is unlikely to lead a legal fight against that decision, although Fair Square is continuing to push for further scrutiny of the process.
