Afcon AFRICA Africans Born Abroad archives Features & Interviews Ghana Latest News world football

Right to Dream Academy scores landmark legal victory over FIFA at CAS

Ernest Nuamah Lyon FCN FC Nordsjaelland 1536x875 1

Ghana’s Right to Dream Academy has won a precedent-setting case at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) that could reshape how FIFA distributes solidarity payments for African footballers, following the record transfer of Ernest Nuamah from FC Nordsjaelland to French side Lyon, Africasoccer.com can exclusively report.

In a ruling seen by AfricaSoccer.com, sport’s highest court overturned a February 2024 FIFA decision that had channelled the bulk of Nuamah’s development compensation to an unconnected grassroots club, Stadium Youth Club, rather than to Right to Dream, where the winger was actually nurtured between the ages of 10 and 18.

CAS has now instructed football’s world governing body to revisit the file, recognising Right to Dream as Nuamah’s principal training centre and ordering a recalculation of the sums owed.

€284,000 — and more to come

When Nuamah left the Danish Superliga for Belgian side RWD Molenbeek in August 2023—before an immediate loan and obligatory purchase by Lyon—the €25 million deal became the most expensive outbound transfer in Danish football history.

Under FIFA statutes, five per cent of every international move is set aside for the player’s formative clubs.

CAS determined that Right to Dream’s share from the first leg of the transfer alone should be €283,919, with further payments due once Lyon’s permanent option is triggered this year.

That figure had originally been earmarked for Stadium Youth Club, which only coached Nuamah until he was eight years old and, according to documents examined by the court, ceased to operate several years ago.

The error stemmed from historic registration data held by the Ghana Football Association.

Tom Vernon Fc Nordsjaelland Right To Dream Park 3922511
Right to Dream Acadedy in Ghana grooms players

FIFA rarely beaten in Lausanne

Legal observers note that FIFA seldom loses at CAS, making this judgment significant for academies across Africa who often rely on solidarity fees to fund youth development.

Right to Dream was represented by Danish sports lawyer Jes Christian Fisker, while FIFA denied wrongdoing throughout the proceedings.

The CAS panel annulled the governing body’s earlier stance and criticised the “inaccurate and outdated” player history on file, instructing Zurich officials to “take into account the evidence produced” during the appeal.

It also emphasised that Right to Dream had already paid nine million Ghanaian cedi (about €700,000) in resale fees to Nuamah’s first organised side, Real Soccer Angels FC, covering the period from his eighth to tenth birthdays.

 

Controversial transfer pathway

Nuamah’s 2023 move attracted scrutiny beyond the solidarity dispute. FC Nordsjaelland—owned by Right to Dream—sold the Ghana international to Belgian top-flight outfit Molenbeek, another club controlled by Lyon majority shareholder John Textor.

Although Danish officials queried whether the transaction constituted an ‘unusual transfer’, they accepted written assurances from the Belgian and French federations that the arrangement complied with regulations.

Nuamah, now 21, has since become a regular for Ghana and has been linked with English Premier League clubs.

He follows a production line that has already yielded national-team stars Mohammed Kudus, Kamaldeen Sulemana and Simon Adingra—all graduates of Right to Dream’s residential academy in Akosombo.

Kudus Adingra
Mohammed Kudus and Aidngra trained at the Right to Dream Academy in Ghana

Implications for African academies

By forcing FIFA to correct its records and redistribute the funds, CAS has underlined the importance of accurate player histories—an area that many African clubs say remains poorly policed.

Development centres on the continent often struggle to trace graduates once they leave for Europe, allowing intermediary teams or defunct institutions to benefit unfairly from solidarity clauses.

Right to Dream’s victory could therefore embolden other academies to challenge FIFA data when discrepancies arise.

The decision is also financially significant: if Lyon conclude their permanent €25 million purchase this summer, the Ghanaian outfit stands to receive an additional windfall under the recalculated scheme.

With CAS remitting the case to FIFA “for immediate reassessment”, the onus is now on football’s governing body to apply the corrected timeline—and, in doing so, set a clearer precedent for future transfers involving African talent.

Related To This Story

Nuhu Adams

About Author

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Slimani Sporting Nvo1
Football Latest News

Islam Slimani Targeted by Four Interested Clubs

Islam Slimani Attracts Premier League Interest Amid Sporting Lisbon Exit Rumours Algerian striker Islam Slimani may be on his way
Younes Bnou Marzouk 710x398 1
Football Latest News

Juventus: Moroccan Younes Bnou Marzouk Loaned to Westerlo

Younes Bnou Marzouk Joins Westerlo on Loan from Juventus 19-year-old Moroccan striker Younes Bnou Marzouk is set for a new
Atsu 300x199 1
Blog Football Foreign Leagues Latest News

CHELSEA RECRUITS GHANAIAN CHRISTIAN ATSU THEN LOANS HIM TO VITESSE ARNHEM

The transfer of Ghanaian attacking midfielder Christian Atsu to Chelsea has been officially confirmed. Atsu signed a 5-year contract with
Faycal Fajr 710x473 1
Football Latest News

La Liga: Fayçal Fajr Delighted to Join Deportivo

Fayçal Fajr Joins Deportivo La Coruña on Three-Year Deal Deportivo La Coruña have officially announced the signing of Fayçal Fajr
Dieumerci Ndongola 710x472 1
Football Latest News

Charleroi: Dieumerci Ndongola Won’t Be Joining Standard Liège

Standard Liège End Pursuit of Dieumerci Ndongola After Rejected Offer Standard Liège have officially withdrawn their interest in Congolese international
Fernandez1 710x398 1
Football Latest News

Guinea: Luis Fernandez No Longer Condemns His Players

Luis Fernandez, the new coach of Syli National, addressed the public for the first time in Guinea since taking the

Discover the ultimate blend of luxury and precision with the best replica watch. This stunning timepiece captures the essence of elegance and performance, making it the perfect accessory for both formal and casual occasions. Elevate your style without compromising your budget—experience sophistication today!

Mobile applications

Our mobile app is optimized for your phone. Download it for free!

Connect With Us

© 2025, Africa Soccer | All Rights Reserved.
WP Radio
WP Radio
OFFLINE LIVE