PSG’s Qatari Era Divides Opinion in France
Since the takeover by Qatari owners in 2011, Paris Saint-Germain have emerged as a formidable force in European football, raising the profile of Ligue 1 and flying the flag for French football on the international stage.
But not everyone is convinced that the transformation has been entirely positive.
Philippe Bilger, a well-known public figure and commentator in France, has taken to his personal blog to voice sharp criticism of what he sees as the changing spirit of the club.
“There are, of course, likeable and respectable individuals at PSG — Sirigu, Jallet, Thiago Silva, Matuidi among them,” he wrote. “But it’s the overall atmosphere of the club, its culture and surroundings that I take issue with.”
Bilger, a former magistrate and long-time observer of French society, says his discomfort began shortly after Qatar Sports Investments took control of the club.
“Ever since Qatar acquired PSG, little things have consistently disturbed me,” he continued. “I can’t stand the theatricality — players exaggerating contact, rolling on the ground at the slightest touch. It gives the team an image that is, frankly, pitiful and laughable.”
His criticism, however, goes beyond behaviour on the pitch. Bilger argues that the club has become a symbol of excess.
“PSG, under Qatari influence, now oozes power and wealth at every level. It’s omnipresent. And that excess — of image, of money — makes you want to cheer for someone else. To long for victories that feel earned, not bought.”
Despite the club’s domestic dominance and increasing stature in Europe, including consistent runs in the UEFA Champions League, PSG continues to polarise opinion in France. For many supporters, the glamour and ambition brought by the Qatari ownership is something to be celebrated. For others, it’s a departure from the identity of a club that once prided itself on grit, youth development, and Parisian flair.
Bilger’s words will likely resonate with traditionalists who feel disconnected from the club’s modern image. But PSG fans will point to the achievements of recent years, the global profile of stars like Kylian Mbappé and Neymar, and the club’s ability to compete with the giants of world football.
One thing is clear: as PSG continues its Qatari-backed rise, it will do so under both applause and scrutiny.
