Anthony Gordon’s Newcastle exit opens surprise door for William Osula

Newcastle United may have found an unexpected solution to one of the key questions created by Anthony Gordon’s summer departure, with William Osula emerging as a potential candidate to become the club’s new first-choice penalty taker ahead of the new Premier League season.

The Magpies are entering a new era with several decisions still to be made, but their opening pre-season fixture may have offered an early clue about how some responsibilities could be shared under the new management setup.

Newcastle began their preparations with a comfortable 3-0 victory over Darlington, but beyond the result, one moment stood out. Osula was handed the responsibility of taking a penalty after Joe Willock was brought down inside the box, and the Denmark international confidently converted from the spot to give Newcastle a two-goal lead.

That opportunity could prove significant as the club looks to replace Gordon, who had established himself as Newcastle’s trusted penalty specialist before his move to Barcelona.

Osula steps into Gordon’s vacant role

Gordon became Newcastle’s leading penalty taker after taking over from Alexander Isak and enjoyed a perfect record from 12 yards last season, converting all nine of his attempts.

With that role now available, competition is expected among the squad’s attacking players. Bruno Guimaraes and Nick Woltemade both successfully converted penalties during the 2025-26 campaign, but recent misses on international duty may have affected their chances of becoming the club’s main option.

According to Chronicle Live’s Sean McCormick, those circumstances could create an opening for Osula, who strengthened his claim by confidently handling the responsibility against Darlington.

The 22-year-old’s growing importance within the squad also adds weight to the possibility. After joining Newcastle’s first-team setup, Osula finished last season as Eddie Howe’s preferred striker ahead of Woltemade and Yoane Wissa, suggesting the forward had earned increasing trust before the managerial transition.

However, with a new coach now in charge, the attacking hierarchy could still change during pre-season.

From squad player to key figure

Osula’s development at Newcastle has been gradual, but the forward made noticeable progress last season as he became a more regular contributor.

The striker featured in 35 matches across all competitions, scoring nine goals and providing two assists. While those numbers do not place him among the club’s top attacking threats yet, his improved involvement and ability to operate in key moments have increased his value to the squad.

Taking penalties requires confidence, composure and the trust of teammates, qualities Osula demonstrated when he stepped forward against Darlington.

The role would represent a significant shift for the young forward, moving him from a developing attacker into a player entrusted with one of the biggest responsibilities at St James’ Park.

A new chapter under fresh leadership

Newcastle’s search for solutions comes as the club prepares for a season of transition. Gordon’s departure has removed one of their most reliable contributors, leaving questions over who will provide goals and leadership in attacking areas.

Osula’s emergence as a possible penalty taker adds another layer to his growing importance, although his long-term role will depend on how the new manager shapes the team.