Hernandez Hernandez criticised after controversial Barcelona victory over Villarreal

Share This Article:
Hernandez Hernandez criticised after controversial Barcelona victory over Villarreal

Hernandez Hernandez was given a rating of 2.5 out of 10 by refereeing website Archivo VAR after Barcelona’s 3-2 win against Villarreal in La Liga’s 13th round.

The assessment said the referee remained unable to recover his best form after what it described as a very poor performance during the match.

Hernandez Hernandez faced a difficult first half and issued several yellow cards which, in Archivo VAR’s view, could have been avoided. He also failed to award Barcelona a clear penalty when Lamine Yamal went down in the area, only stopping play and reviewing the incident on the pitch after being alerted by the video assistant referee team.

His handling of individual incidents improved slightly after the interval, but the disciplinary approach remained largely unchanged. More yellow cards were shown despite the website judging several of them to be unnecessary.

Four incidents under review

The match contained four notable refereeing incidents. Archivo VAR said Hernandez Hernandez appeared to have made two correct decisions and one incorrect decision among three particularly contentious situations, while also highlighting the corner awarded before Barcelona’s opening goal.

The first major incident involved Yamal, with the referee initially overlooking what was considered a clear penalty before reviewing the footage on the stadium screen.

Hernandez Hernandez later showed Pau Navarro a second yellow card, resulting in his dismissal. That decision was judged to be correct.

However, moments before the sending-off, the referee did not award a foul which could have led to a penalty. Archivo VAR said the situation was better suited to an on-field decision than intervention from the video assistant referee.

The incident involved Gerard Martin making contact with Ayoze in the face with his hand while the two players competed for position. Although the website said the incident did not warrant a VAR intervention because there was no conclusive evidence over the force of the contact, it believed a penalty should have been awarded on the field because it was a direct blow to the face and did not occur during a direct challenge for the ball.

The final point concerned the corner given in the move immediately before Barcelona scored their first goal. It appeared the Villarreal goalkeeper had not touched the ball, meaning a corner should not have been awarded.

Nevertheless, Archivo VAR noted that there was no sufficiently clear footage to verify the incident conclusively. As a result, the decision made on the pitch remains the official ruling.

Share This Article: