Barcelona’s penalty against Villarreal was correctly awarded after a VAR review, according to specialist account Archivo VAR, although Lamine Yamal struck the post with the resulting spot-kick.
Referee Alejandro Hernandez Hernandez initially reviewed the incident during Sunday evening’s first half before awarding the penalty in the 21st minute. Yamal had gone down inside the area following contact with Villarreal forward Tani Oluwaseyi.
Archivo VAR said the video assistant referee was right to intervene and support the decision.
“VAR had to assist referee Hernandez Hernandez,” the account said in its analysis on X.
It added: “Oluwaseyi impeded Lamine Yamal’s movement by making contact with him twice, first from below and then from above.”
The account concluded: “Correct penalty.”
Its explanation focused on the timing of the first contact. Yamal had already begun to fall when the second challenge took place, meaning the initial contact was the decisive factor in the decision.
The analysis therefore did not rely simply on the existence of contact between the two players. Instead, it determined that the first intervention directly affected Yamal’s balance and caused him to fall, making a penalty appropriate.
A subsequent touch after a player has started to go down does not necessarily cancel out an earlier foul if that initial contact was the main cause of the loss of balance.
Yamal hits the post
Barcelona were given an opportunity to reduce their deficit in the 23rd minute, but Yamal was unable to convert the penalty. His effort struck the right-hand post of Villarreal’s goal, denying the hosts a chance to move back into the contest.
The incident came during an eventful first half in which Villarreal took a 2-0 lead despite Barcelona dominating possession and producing more attacking pressure.
Tajon Buchanan opened the scoring for Villarreal in the fifth minute after capitalising on a defensive error by Barcelona. Tani Oluwaseyi then doubled the visitors’ advantage two minutes later, with Alberto Moleiro providing the assist.
Barcelona controlled most of the play and finished the half with 74% possession, compared with Villarreal’s 26%. They also recorded 13 attempts to Villarreal’s three, while their expected goals figure stood at 1.16 against 0.11 for the visitors.
However, Yamal’s missed penalty meant Barcelona went into half-time still trailing 2-0. The failure to take the opportunity left manager Hansi Flick facing the task of turning the match around after the interval.
Archivo VAR’s assessment settled the debate over the referee’s decision: the penalty was valid, but Barcelona failed to benefit from the chance it created.
