The penalty awarded to Kylian Mbappe during Real Madrid’s match against Celta Vigo was the correct decision, according to refereeing analysis account Archivo VAR.
Mbappe was preparing to shoot at the Santiago Bernabeu when Celta Vigo defender Javi Rodriguez held him. The contact disrupted the France forward’s balance and led the referee to point to the spot. The decision was subsequently confirmed by the Video Assistant Referee.
Archivo VAR reviewed the incident and concluded that Rodriguez’s intervention warranted a penalty, even though the action was not an especially obvious or forceful grab.
The account said the defender had held Mbappe by the wrist at the precise moment he was attempting to strike the ball. That affected the forward’s movement and prevented him from taking the shot in a normal manner.
Its assessment was that the effect of the contact on Mbappe’s ability to complete the action was more important than how dramatic the hold appeared. Although the challenge was not excessive, the interference with the player’s movement was sufficient for a foul to be given inside the area.
The decision gave Real Madrid a valuable opportunity to recover in the match. Mbappe took responsibility for the spot-kick, with the chance to equalise and prevent his side from dropping points against Celta Vigo.
However, his attempt went badly wrong. The France international struck the ball high over the crossbar, sending it into the stands and wasting one of Real Madrid’s clearest opportunities of the game.
The miss frustrated supporters inside the Santiago Bernabeu, where whistles greeted the penalty. Real Madrid had struggled to impose an attacking rhythm and produced a subdued display against opponents who made use of the space available to them.
Celta Vigo threatened the home goal on several occasions, while Real Madrid were unable to turn their possession and attacking intentions into sustained pressure. The home side therefore reached the end of the first half trailing 1-0.
Archivo VAR’s review addressed the main point of controversy from the match, determining that the referee’s decision was not an attempt to favour Real Madrid but a technically correct response to the contact from Rodriguez.
The incident remained significant because it combined a penalty decision supported by VAR with a missed opportunity that could have changed the course of the contest. Instead, Mbappe’s poor execution left Real Madrid without the equaliser they had been offered.
