Upamecano’s Bayern revival leaves De Ligt facing an uncertain Manchester United future
Bayern Munich’s decision to sell Matthijs de Ligt and retain Dayot Upamecano, one of the club’s most divisive choices in recent years, has increasingly appeared to favour the French defender.
The move angered Bayern supporters, with 71,840 people signing an online petition titled “Keep De Ligt! We want De Ligt!” The Dutchman, who joined Manchester United for 45m euros in August 2024, also acknowledged the backing, saying: “This touches my heart.”
Yet the two defenders’ careers have since taken sharply different directions.
When Vincent Kompany became Bayern manager in the summer of 2024, he inherited five centre-backs: Upamecano, Min-Jae Kim, De Ligt, Eric Dier and new signing Hiroki Ito. One of them was expected to leave, and reports suggested Upamecano was not initially the leading candidate for a sale.
Kompany, however, believed the France international’s physical strength and pace suited the tactical approach he wanted to introduce. De Ligt was consequently allowed to depart, despite having become a popular figure at Bayern.
The Netherlands international had arrived from Juventus in the summer of 2022 for 67m euros, after establishing himself as one of European football’s leading defensive talents at Ajax Amsterdam. Signed during Julian Nagelsmann’s time in charge, the then 22-year-old impressed in his first season and finished second to Jamal Musiala in the Bayern supporters’ player-of-the-year vote.
His leadership, commitment and combative style made him a fans’ favourite. Many supporters were unconvinced by the decision to keep Upamecano, who had been criticised for costly mistakes and recurring fitness problems.
Bayern sporting director Max Eberl defended the decision in November, saying: “It is not about feeling that we have won. Matthijs de Ligt was also a top-class centre-back, but we had to make a decision, and we made it. It is paying off.”
Upamecano has since become a key part of the defence, initially alongside Kim and, at the start of the 2025-26 season, alongside new signing Jonathan Tah. Bayern rewarded him with a contract extension until 2030 and a signing bonus estimated at about 20m euros at the beginning of 2026.
De Ligt’s time at Manchester United has been disrupted by criticism, poor team results and a back injury sustained in autumn 2025. Ruben Amorim initially described the problem as “a minor issue”, but repeated setbacks kept the defender out for months. He underwent surgery in May, ending his season and damaging his hopes of playing for the Netherlands at the World Cup.
He returned in late October against Como Calcio in the Champions League, a 4-1 defeat, but made only one further brief appearance in the competition. His last Premier League match came on 30 November 2025, leaving him absent from domestic action for almost a year.
With Michael Carrick favouring Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez, De Ligt was overlooked even when Martinez was suspended, as right-back Leny Yoro and 20-year-old Ayden Heaven were used at centre-back.
Carrick’s dismissal during the international break and the appointment of Mauricio Pochettino have added to the uncertainty. Although De Ligt’s contract runs until 2029, he is now considered a possible departure in January or at the end of the season. Manchester United great Gary Neville has said: “De Ligt must leave.”
Inter Milan and Turkish club Besiktas are reportedly interested in the 27-year-old, while Upamecano’s rise has given Bayern increasing grounds to believe Kompany’s judgement was correct.
