Steven Caulker backs Mauricio Pochettino to revive Man United but warns problems run deeper than management

Share This Article:
Steven Caulker backs Mauricio Pochettino to revive Man United but warns problems run deeper than management

Former Premier League defender Steven Caulker believes Mauricio Pochettino faces a difficult task in restoring Manchester United’s fortunes, insisting the club’s problems extend beyond the managerial position.

Pochettino has arrived at Old Trafford with the responsibility of stabilising a struggling side, but Caulker believes the Argentine will need time and patience to address the deeper issues affecting the club.

In his exclusive column for Flashscore, the former Sierra Leone international questioned Manchester United’s repeated managerial changes, arguing that the club’s lack of consistency has contributed significantly to its decline.

United have appointed 12 managers over the past 13 seasons, a remarkable contrast to the 26-year reign of Sir Alex Ferguson, who delivered sustained success before leaving the club in 2013.

Caulker, who experienced playing against Ferguson’s Manchester United during his time at Tottenham Hotspur, recalled the difficulty of visiting Old Trafford and the remarkable atmosphere surrounding the club.

He particularly remembered Tottenham’s 3-2 victory over United, a result that was significant given their struggles to win at the stadium.

However, he pointed out that Ferguson’s departure, rather than that defeat, marked the beginning of the club’s prolonged decline.

Caulker questions United’s costly managerial merry-go-round

Caulker believes Manchester United’s continued changes in leadership have come at a considerable financial cost without delivering the desired results.

According to the former defender, the club has spent more than £100 million on appointing and dismissing managers, with £7.4 million reportedly paid to release Pochettino from his contract with the United States national team.

He questioned the timing of the appointment, arguing that United could have secured the Argentine without paying compensation before he agreed to a new deal.

The decision to give Michael Carrick an opportunity before eventually dismissing him after just 10 league matches also attracted criticism from Caulker, who noted that the club paid another £2.9 million in compensation.

He believes managerial changes alone will not resolve the problems affecting the team, particularly the apparent lack of accountability among senior players.

Caulker acknowledged that Carrick had performed well during the previous season but suggested that his relationship with some players deteriorated.

He also criticised the public comments made by Lisandro Martinez and Bruno Fernandes following disappointing results, insisting that players must first take responsibility for their own performances.

Three days to prepare for Liverpool

Pochettino faces an immediate examination of his managerial credentials, with just three days to prepare Manchester United for Sunday’s Premier League showdown against Liverpool at Anfield.

Caulker, who is also pursuing a career in coaching, believes the limited preparation period will prevent the new manager from implementing significant tactical changes before the encounter.

Instead, he expects Pochettino to prioritise restoring confidence and improving the team’s mentality.

Drawing from his own playing experience, Caulker recalled how former Queens Park Rangers manager Ian Holloway used unconventional methods to motivate his players.

He revealed that Holloway once gathered the entire squad in the canteen and made them watch the film Coach Carter for more than two hours before incorporating references from the movie into his tactical instructions.

Although he does not expect Pochettino to adopt a similar approach, Caulker believes the Argentine must find a way to unite the dressing room and prepare his players mentally for the Liverpool challenge.

Having previously managed high-profile players at Paris Saint-Germain, Chelsea and Tottenham, Pochettino is expected to have the experience required to handle the personalities within the United squad.

Caulker identifies defence as Pochettino’s priority

Beyond the psychological challenge, Caulker believes improving Manchester United’s defensive organisation should be Pochettino’s immediate priority.

United have conceded 19 goals in the Premier League this season, leaving them among the division’s worst defensive sides.

He warned that Liverpool’s attacking options, including Alexander Isak, Bradley Barcola, Florian Wirtz, Victor Munoz and Cody Gakpo, could expose United’s defensive weaknesses if they fail to improve their organisation.

Caulker expects Pochettino to focus on establishing a solid defensive foundation before attempting to introduce the expansive football associated with his previous teams.

With limited time on the training ground, he suggested that video analysis and tactical meetings could prove particularly important in preparing the players for Sunday’s encounter.

The former defender also identified Harry Maguire as the player he would build United’s defence around, believing the England international possesses the experience and character to lead the backline.

“In my personal opinion, I would build the defence around Harry Maguire. I would give him the confidence to lead and organise on the pitch. He has overcome so much adversity and can be an example for many,” Caulker wrote.

He also highlighted Pochettino’s man-management abilities, referencing former Tottenham defender Danny Rose’s glowing assessment of the Argentine’s attention to detail and commitment to developing his players.

Rose previously described Pochettino as the best manager he had worked with, praising his meticulous approach to every aspect of the football environment.

Top-half finish should be United’s target

Despite the challenges awaiting Pochettino, Caulker believes the Argentine can restore some of Manchester United’s lost identity if he receives sufficient backing and time.

He considers a top-half finish in the Premier League a realistic measure of success for the remainder of the campaign, alongside rebuilding the team’s confidence and establishing a recognisable playing philosophy.

However, Caulker stressed that the responsibility should not rest entirely on the new manager, insisting that the players, club hierarchy and supporters must also play their part in the rebuilding process.

He believes patience will be crucial if Manchester United are to move away from the instability that has characterised their post-Ferguson era.

Share This Article: