Gary Neville believes Manchester United should part company with Noussair Mazraoui, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt before considering Diogo Dalot’s future at Old Trafford.
Dalot has faced criticism for his performances during the current season, as Manchester United’s results and defensive displays have declined. But former United defender Neville says the Portugal international has become an easy target and is not receiving enough support from those around him.
With Mauricio Pochettino now in charge at Manchester United, Neville has urged the Argentine not to make a rushed decision over Dalot. He believes the full-back’s performances should be judged alongside the defence’s collective display.
“I think if he was playing in a good back four, he would be in a better position,” Neville said on the Stick to United programme while speaking to Mark Goldbridge.
“But his back four is catastrophic, his position is not ideal, and he can improve with the ball and in everything he does. However, I think he has become far too easy a target.”
Neville, as reported by the Daily Mail, said he sometimes heard friends who support Manchester United mocking Dalot, prompting him to question whether they were seeing something he was not.
He said his defensive rebuild would begin with Mazraoui, Martinez and de Ligt leaving the club, rather than Dalot.
“I would get rid of Mazraoui long before Dalot, and Martinez as well. De Ligt too,” Neville said.
“He has a big problem because he does not play football. If a player is injury-prone and does not play regularly, you cannot favour him over someone who plays every week. You want a player you can rely on and who is involved consistently.”
Neville said Martinez would be among his departures without hesitation and repeated his concerns about the Argentine defender. He also pointed to de Ligt’s recurring injuries as a reason why the Netherlands international could be moved on during the next phase of change.
His proposed overhaul would retain Luke Shaw, Harry Maguire, Leny Yoro and Dalot. Neville believes Shaw deserves another opportunity under Pochettino because the manager knows his ability, although the England left-back’s injury record may force United to sign another player in that position.
“He will keep Shaw because he knows him well and may be able to get the best out of him,” Neville added. “But his problem is injuries, so he will have to manage him carefully, and he will also need to sign a left-back.”
Neville expects Maguire to stay because Pochettino could trust him to carry out the required defensive duties. He also sees potential in Yoro, despite weaknesses in the French defender’s current performances.
Yoro can sometimes look thin and lack physical balance, Neville said, comparing his movement to “Bambi on ice”. However, he believes the defender has considerable room for improvement as he gains strength and experience.
Yoro’s call-up to the France squad indicates his potential, Neville added, although he still needs to develop his physical power and consistency in one-on-one battles. He cited Rio Ferdinand’s development at Manchester United after Sir Alex Ferguson identified the need for greater strength.
Neville concluded that Pochettino would need to sign at least three new defenders to build a competitive back line, while retaining Shaw, Maguire, Yoro and Dalot.
His criticism of Martinez comes as the defender continues to appear for Manchester United this season, despite criticising the club’s management in an interview last month. That has placed him firmly in discussions about the future of United’s defence.
