Miguel Cardoso faces a more immediate threat to his position than Kaizer Chiefs head coach Fernando da Cruz as Mamelodi Sundowns prepare to meet Amakhosi in Sunday’s Carling Knockout Cup semi-final.
The two managers go into the match at Loftus Versfeld under scrutiny, but the nature and intensity of that pressure are different. Cardoso is likely to be one defeat away from losing his job after Sundowns’ disappointing continental campaign.
Sundowns have established themselves as one of Africa’s leading clubs, making their recent results particularly damaging. Their CAF Champions League run ended with a shock defeat by Angolan club Wiliete SC, before they were beaten 3-1 by USM Alger in the CAF Super Cup final.
Failing to reach the Champions League group stages represented a major setback for a side whose ambitions extend well beyond domestic competition. The triumph in the MTN8 earlier this season provides Cardoso with some protection, and Sundowns remain competitive in South Africa.
However, their continental failures have led to renewed questions over whether the Portuguese coach can deliver the level of success expected by the club.
Da Cruz has greater backing
Da Cruz has also faced frustration since taking charge at Kaizer Chiefs. The club have lacked consistency, lost the Soweto Derby to Orlando Pirates and were knocked out of the CAF Confederation Cup by Zambian side Red Arrows following a penalty shootout.
Those results have added to the disappointment among supporters who want Amakhosi to challenge regularly for major honours again.
There is nevertheless a significant difference between the situations of the two coaches. Following Chiefs’ continental exit, sporting director Kaizer Motaung Jnr publicly confirmed the club’s support for Da Cruz and his technical staff.
Motaung Jnr also emphasised the importance of the club’s long-term project, indicating that the Frenchman has been given time to develop his work. That backing does not eliminate the pressure surrounding results, but it gives Da Cruz more room to recover.
Cardoso does not appear to have the same margin for error. At Sundowns, domestic trophies on their own are not considered sufficient when the club’s wider expectations include competing successfully on the continent.
A place in the final at stake
The semi-final offers both managers the chance to reduce the scrutiny around them.
Victory would provide Da Cruz with a strong argument that his project at Chiefs is moving in the right direction. For Cardoso, success would help rebuild confidence after the club’s damaging continental setbacks.
Both coaches need a positive result, but the consequences are potentially greater for Cardoso. Another defeat would increase the pressure on his leadership and further question his ability to meet Sundowns’ highest ambitions.
The match starts at 3.30 at Loftus Versfeld Stadium, with a place in the Carling Knockout final at stake.
